- Home
- A-Z Publications
- Journal of New Zealand & Pacific Studies
- Previous Issues
- Volume 11, Issue 2, 2023
Journal of New Zealand & Pacific Studies - Volume 11, Issue 2, 2023
Volume 11, Issue 2, 2023
- Editorial
-
-
-
Editorial
By Ian ConrichThe whānau, or family, that consists of members of the New Zealand Studies Association (NZSA) and that meets once a year at the Association’s hui, or conference, is a rich gathering of delegates old and new. In the last year NZSA lost three distinguished colleagues from its whānau: Fay Weldon, John Dunmore and Grant McCall. Members of the whānau may depart, but they remain alive through their words, contributions and debates. Two of the four articles in this issue are extensions of papers given at NZSA’s 2023 conference in Stockholm-Turku and this includes a contribution by Witi Ihimaera, who was one of the conference keynote speakers. Questions of indigeneity, identity and Māoritanga are vital to both these articles. They are also important to a third article, which examines taonga pūoro as cultural artefacts that can assist in reconsidering the extent of where the Indigenous peoples of Aotearoa came from. A fourth article on Indonesia’s annexation of West Papua and the role of the United Nations, also adopts a revisionist approach.
-
-
- Articles
-
-
-
Sounding out the ‘Hawaiki zone’: What musical instruments reveal about the immediate geographical origins of the peoples who became Māori in Aotearoa
More LessA range of linguistic, genetic and archaeological evidence supports the immediate ancestors of Māori having come from central Eastern Polynesia, and this is borne out through a comparative study of central Eastern Polynesian and Māori musical instruments. An examination of Māori musical instruments also shows, however, that a few instrument names, types and usages may be adoptions or adaptations from elsewhere in Oceania – from Hawai‘i, or from Western Polynesia or Eastern Melanesia. While the possibility of convergent evolution cannot be ruled out, these similarities are quite striking and raise some intriguing questions. Are these similarities the result of cultural transmission to central Eastern Polynesia from Hawai‘i and Western Polynesia (and/or Eastern Melanesia) prior to the departure of the ancestors of Māori to Aotearoa? Could they be the result of a limited amount of direct voyaging from Western Polynesia and/or Eastern Melanesia to Aotearoa prior to the Little Ice Age (c.1400), or from later cultural transmission? Are they the vestiges of practices that, in historical times, had been discontinued in central Eastern Polynesia but preserved in marginal Polynesia (as per the ‘stone in the pond’ model of cultural diffusion)? These questions are discussed in this article, which aims to shed further light on the possible origins of Māori musical instruments and, in so doing, the immediate geographical origins of Māori ancestors.
-
-
-
-
Writing outward into the international world
More LessThis was written first as a keynote speech, which was given at the midway point of the 27th annual conference of the New Zealand Studies Association, held in Stockholm, Sweden, and Turku, Finland, 26–30 June 2023. It was originally entitled ‘The Māori anthologist’ and addressed the politics and aesthetics of my career as an editor of some sixteen anthologies of, mainly, Māori and New Zealand literature. But after listening to the papers that had been presented, which primarily covered the South Pacific, I decided to alter my presentation and offer a personal intervention on my career as a Pacific rather than a Māori writer, ranging from The Whale Rider (1987) through to Navigating the Stars: Māori Creation Myths (2020). Furthermore, the presentation now responded to themes of Pacific and Oceanic transnationality and transculturality, which had arisen from the conference. This article is both a consolidation and extension of thoughts and arguments that were given in that keynote speech, with identity and indigeneity key concerns.
-
-
-
Warrior-matriarchs’ retrotopia and democracy: Searching for the lost tribe in Alan Duff’s Once Were Warriors
More LessThe novel Once Were Warriors (1990), by Alan Duff, demystified the Māori grand narratives of the past previously romanticized by writings from the Māori Renaissance of the mid-1970s and 1980s. In contrast with the negative portrayal of Māori subjectivities and the political immobility generally perceived by critics, this study aims to reconceptualize male tribal models in Duff’s novel. On the one hand, the rangatira (or male elders) and Māori urban gangs engage in tribal patterns echoing utopias of male domination. Whilst on the other hand, female characters such as Beth Heke, her daughter Grace and the singer Mavis Tangata – as examples of warrior-matriarchs – suggest a recuperation of ancestral warriorhood through open democracy and the hybridity of a revised version of tribalism and the Eucharist.
-
-
-
Re-thinking agents of empire: The role of the United Nations in the Indonesian occupation of West Papua
Authors: Dominic Alessio and Imogen AlessioThe years post-World War II were not necessarily a period of independence for everyone. This is especially the case for a number of Pacific locales, West Papua in particular, wherein one colonial power seems to have merely been switched for another. What is more, this takeover was done with the connivance of the United Nations (UN), a non-state agency which, following World War II, was designed to maintain the peace. By way of the 1969 UN-brokered Act of Free Choice, the peoples of this former Dutch colony were instead subjected to an invading Indonesian military and colonial culture. This work, whilst not only drawing attention to an under-discussed process of recolonization in the Pacific, focuses upon another, albeit overlooked method by which empires can be created, namely by way of a non-state agency. In doing so it critiques theories of empire that concentrate primarily upon large state-led entities characterized by physical conquest. Whilst it is true that big state-led powers with vast military forces bent on conquering other sovereign states are the most easily discernible of empires, we argue that this is only one type and that colonialism needs to be differentiated. We suggest that other actors, including non-state players such as private companies, religious organizations, filibusters and now, as emphasized here, international/inter-governmental organizations, should be scrutinized too.
-
- Obituary
-
- Book Reviews
-
-
-
A Primer for Teaching Pacific Histories: Ten Design Principles, Matt K. Matsuda (2020)
By Paul D’ArcyReview of: A Primer for Teaching Pacific Histories: Ten Design Principles, Matt K. Matsuda (2020)
Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 172 pp.,
ISBN 978 1 47800 847 7 (pbk), US$24.95
-
-
-
-
Ignored Histories: The Politics of History Education and Indigenous Settler Relations in Australia and Kanaky/New Caledonia, Angélique Stastny (2022)
More LessReview of: Ignored Histories: The Politics of History Education and Indigenous Settler Relations in Australia and Kanaky/New Caledonia, Angélique Stastny (2022)
Honolulu, HI: The University of Hawai‘i Press, 280 pp.,
ISBN 978 0 82488 997 5 (hbk), US$68
-
-
-
If Everyone Returned, the Island Would Sink: Urbanisation and Migration in Vanuatu, Kirstie Petrou (2020)
By Rudy BessardReview of: If Everyone Returned, The Island Would Sink: Urbanisation and Migration in Vanuatu, Kirstie Petrou (2020)
New York and Oxford: Berghahn, 214 pp.,
ISBN 978 1 78920 621 0 (hbk), US$135
-
-
-
The Men Who Would Be King, Jon Tonks (Photographs) and Christopher Lord (Text) (2021)
More LessReview of: The Men Who Would be King, Jon Tonks (Photographs) and Christopher Lord (Text) (2021)
Stockport: Dewi Lewis Publishing, 200 pp.,
ISBN 978 1 91130 643 6 (hbk), £39.00
-
-
-
The New Port Moresby: Gender Space and Belonging in Urban Papua New Guinea, Ceridwen Spark (2020)
By Max QuanchiReview of: The New Port Moresby: Gender, Space, and Belonging in Urban Papua New Guinea, Ceridwen Spark (2020)
Honolulu, HI: University of Hawai‘i Press, 174 pp.,
ISBN 978 0 82488 180 1 (hbk), US$80
ISBN 978 0 82488 980 7 (pbk), US$30
-
-
-
12 jours à Nuku Hiva: Rencontres et révolte russe dans le Pacifique Sud (12 Days at Nuku Hiva: Russian Encounters and Mutiny in the South Pacific), Elena Govor (2021)
More LessReview of: 12 jours à Nuku Hiva: Rencontres et révolte russe dans le Pacifique Sud (12 Days at Nuku Hiva: Russian Encounters and Mutiny in the South Pacific), Elena Govor (2021)
Leiden: Sidestone Press, 406 pp.,
ISBN 978 9 46426 018 2 (pbk), €60
-
-
-
Island Time: New Zealand’s Pacific Futures, Damon Salesa (2017)
By Tom RyanReview of: Island Time: New Zealand’s Pacific Futures, Damon Salesa (2017)
Wellington: Bridget Williams Books, 256 pp.,
ISBN 978 1 98853 353 7 (pbk), NZ$17.99
-
-
-
Politics in a Pandemic: Jacinda Ardern and New Zealand’s 2020 Election, Stephen Levine (ed.) (2021)
More LessReview of: Politics in a Pandemic: Jacinda Ardern and New Zealand’s 2020 Election, Stephen Levine (ed.) (2021)
Wellington: Victoria University Press
(Te Herenga Waka University Press), 504 pp.,
ISBN 978 1 77656 433 0 (pbk), NZ$50
-
-
-
From Suffrage to a Seat in the House: The Path to Parliament for New Zealand Women, Jenny Coleman (2020)
More LessReview of: From Suffrage to a Seat in the House: The Path to Parliament for New Zealand Women, Jenny Coleman (2020)
Dunedin: Otago University Press, 338 pp.,
ISBN 978 1 98859 226 8 (pbk), NZ$45.00
-
-
-
Dressed: Fashionable Dress in Aotearoa New Zealand 1840 to 1910, Claire Regnault (2021)
More LessReview of: Dressed: Fashionable Dress in Aotearoa New Zealand 1840 to 1910, Claire Regnault (2021)
Wellington: Te Papa Press, 456 pp.,
ISBN 978 0 99414 606 9 (hbk), NZ$70.00
-
-
-
Hundertwasser in New Zealand: The Art of Creating Paradise, Andreas J. Hirsch (2022), Translated by Uta Hoffmann
By Leonard BellReview of: Hundertwasser in New Zealand: The Art of Creating Paradise, Andreas J. Hirsch (2022), Translated by Uta Hoffmann
Auckland: Oratia Books, 240 pp.,
ISBN 978 1 99004 214 0 (hbk), NZ$70.00
-
-
-
Eye of the Taika: New Zealand Comedy and the Films of Taika Waititi, Matthew Bannister (2021)
More LessReview of: Eye of the Taika: New Zealand Comedy and the Films of Taika Waititi, Matthew Bannister (2021)
Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press, 312 pp.,
ISBN 978 0 81434 533 7 (pbk), US$36.99
-
-
-
Navigating Chamoru Poetry: Indigeneity, Aesthetics, and Decolonization, Craig Santos Perez (2021)
More LessReview of: Navigating Chamoru Poetry: Indigeneity, Aesthetics, and Decolonization, Craig Santos Perez (2021)
Tuscon, AZ: University of Arizona Press, 254 pp.,
ISBN 978 0 81653 550 7 (pbk), US$35
-
-
-
No Other Place to Stand: An Anthology of Climate Change Poetry from Aotearoa New Zealand, Jordan Hamel, Rebecca Hawkes, Erik Kennedy and Essa Ranapiri (2022)
More LessReview of: No Other Place to Stand: An Anthology of Climate Change Poetry from Aotearoa New Zealand, Jordan Hamel, Rebecca Hawkes, Erik Kennedy and Essa Ranapiri (2022)
Auckland: Auckland University Press, 220 pp.,
ISBN 978 1 86940 955 5 (pbk), NZ$29.99
-