Film Studies
From Montalbano to Savastanos: The circulation of Italian crime dramas in Spain
This article seeks to map the Italian crime dramas broadcast in Spain. Then we move on to the twenty-first century to analyse the scope of Italian TV crime in contemporary Spanish TV. As case studies for our investigation, we use the circulation and reception in Spain of two Italian series: Il commissario Montalbano (El comisario Montalbano, Inspector Montalbano) (1999–2021) and Gomorra – La serie (Gomorra, Gomorrah) (2014–21). Using a political economy approach, we first examine the reception of the literary sources by Andrea Camilleri and Roberto Saviano. Second, we contextualize the significant shifts in the Spanish media landscape where those series were broadcast. Third, we determine why and how these TV series were useful and appealing to Spanish programmers. The research is complemented with audience data, an analysis of the series’ aesthetics and their critical reception.
Will the real Montalbano please stand up: Camilleri’s detective on the page and on-screen
This article explores the relationship between Andrea Camilleri’s Inspector Montalbano novels and the RAI TV series, Il commissario Montalbano. While both are successful, the televised version has turned Montalbano into a household name across Italy, ranking as the most successful giallo production on RAI. The analysis delves into disparities between Camilleri’s literary character and the TV persona, examining alterations made for commercial viability. Focusing on recurring visual elements – geographic imagery and female beauty – the series addresses sensitive themes. The article concludes that the TV adaptation, not aiming for faithful reproduction, targets a different audience. It effectively adjusts the original message using cinematographic techniques, emphasizing female beauty, food and slapstick comedy to entertain while navigating uncomfortable topics.
Female leads in contemporary Italian crime drama: Industry, narratives and reconfiguration of gender in Rai Fiction (2016–21)
The paper examines the changing portrayal of female leads in Italian crime television drama, focusing specifically on RAI productions from 2016 to 2021. While the number of women protagonists has grown considerably in recent years, gender representation remains uneven and often characterised by ambivalence and contradiction – particularly in portrayals of female professionalism. Using content and character analysis, the study is divided into two parts. The first traces the historical marginalisation of women in Italian crime serials, where male protagonists traditionally held dominance in both narrative and professional authority. The second explores how contemporary series depict gender through postfeminist perspectives, balancing between innovative representations and lingering stereotypes. It contends that, although significant progress has been made in diversifying female characters – especially through more complex narrative roles and professional identities – such progress is frequently limited by romantic subplots and traditional gender norms. The article places these findings within wider discussions on narrative complexity, production culture and the symbolic role of public service broadcasting in shaping gender discourse.
Valley of crime: The Po Valley as the theatre for Italian television crime drama in the third millennium
Adopting the interdisciplinary approach of location studies, this article focuses on TV series set in the Po Valley, which in the past twenty years has become – both from the point of view of current events and from that of the related television fictional representations – a social and narrative theatre of murky mysteries and heinous crimes. In this TV series, the visual innovation of the ‘provincial’ Padanian context is further amplified by complex narratives, ambiguous anti-heroes and unconventional female characters, who renegotiate the rules of gender. Lending itself not only as a topical film-television location but also as an authentic ‘actor’ – around which the most hidden fears and the most brutal instincts of the Italian history of the third millennium are condensed – the peripheral Padanian geography lends itself to localize universal stories, thus reshaping the entire audience’s collective imagination regarding ‘Italianness’.
ESP, Extra: Liminal investigations between chronicle, conspiracy theories, paranormal and new cults
At the beginning of the 1970s, the landscape of Italian television dramas intersects with transforming trends, allowing the crime genre to emerge as a fertile ground for experimentation. Detective stories draw upon 1970s counterculture and open up a cryptic universe no longer knowable by reason alone. Thus, a new narrative movement begins that lasts the entire decade, inspired by the subjects of the fantastic with supernatural mysteries dominated by the occult. These productions deconstruct the pedagogical mission of early television and find new trajectories for television drama. The most groundbreaking works of this period are often forgotten or confined to the category of minor productions: ESP and Extra. First framing the period historically, and then turning to a textual and culturological analysis of the two titles, this article attempts to shed light on the fracture created by the two sceneggiati in Italian TV. It explores the way these works recounted 1970s society and prefigured that of today.
Engaging with complex television crime drama: Moral and artistic value in Gomorra: La serie (Seasons 1–3) and Twitter audience responses
Using Gomorra: La serie (Seasons 1–3) as a case study, this article examines how complex television crime drama engages with moral and artistic values. It proposes a novel framework that integrates analytic aesthetics with empirical audience research and film analysis to investigate whether and how this genre can shape viewers’ moral responses. The first section outlines the critical and public discourse surrounding the series. The second introduces the concept of ‘cinematic moralism’ to describe how Gomorrah’s narrative and stylistic choices are meant to elicit a morally reflective response from viewers. The final section explores how Twitter users engage with the series’ ethical cues, revealing a disconnect between intended and actual audience responses. The article supports a cautious view, suggesting that while fiction may invite moral reflection, empirical evidence does not confirm its power to improve moral judgment or function reliably as a source of moral learning. This conclusion aligns with Gregory Currie’s call for caution regarding the idea that fiction can serve as a reliable source of moral knowledge.
Introduction: Essay Filmmaking as Creative Research
Foregrounding the thinking and reflective process so candidly on screen, the essay film form still involves a (hidden) process of conceiving and making. However, to this time, very little research has been done on the thinking process involved in essay filmmaking. Thus, this volume is a collective discussion on what we call the screen writing process in essay filmmaking. Essayistic non-fiction scripts and the documentation of production and editing procedures rarely make it into the archives. As editors, we both feel the importance of exploring this process of screen writing for essay film, which is beyond a conventional understanding of ‘screen-writing’, i.e. scriptwriting prior to the making of a film, as essay filmmaking usually involves a spontaneous process of writing, re-writing with images and sound on the timeline. Decades of reflection on Alexandre Astruc's idea that the camera and lens are the equivalent of the writer's pen (1948, 1968) have not produced an equivalent of analysis of the craft. Different in definition, and somehow more to the point for this volume, Agnes Varda's cinecriture (ciné-writing) (1986) added to the debate and indicated that the essay film needs more process-oriented attempts for the identification of the filmmaker's act of scriptural activity via images and sound. Thus, in this edited collection, we ask: how does an essay film come into being? What are the methods involved in the making of an essay film? What is the screening-writing process during the essay filmmaking? And how do filmmakers make creative and intellectual decisions? We invite artist-filmmakers and practitioner-theorists to reflect on these questions. The provisional idea of the collection, born out of the discussions held during the Symposium at the University of York and The Interdisciplinary Centre for Narrative Studies (2017), Essay Film and Narrative Techniques: First Symposium of the BAFTSS Essay Film Research Group, organized by Romana Turina and Richard Walsh, 18–19 November 2017 in the Bowland Auditorium, addressed a need for further discussion on the essay film form.
The Collector/Sampler/Editor: A Feminist Perspective on the Screenwriting Process
This article engages with the audio-visual essay film production process through a feminist film-philosophical lens by arguing that useful parallels can be established between screen writing for the audio-visual essay film format and the novel work of the feminist philosopher Luce Irigaray. In doing so, it reveals the ethical, political and poetical potential of the screenwriting process. My central contention is that both the screenwriting process for the audio-visual essay film format and Irigaray's work share the same method of production, what I call “caressing mimetic play”. Drawing on my own experimental audio-visual essay A caressing dialogical encounter (UK, 2019, 22:05 mins), I argue that Irigaray's concept of the caress is not only useful as a philosophical tool but also as a novel methodological tool, affording the possibility of formulating and envisioning an alternative screen- writing space, full of new potential for feminist essay film production processes.
Chaos or Process? Some Remarks on the Work Process of an Essay Film
To progress in the financing, developing, and organising a film production, a producer has to make applications and send letters to various places. To be convincing, there must be the script for the film. What to do, when the director doesn't want to write a script, even though he is a talented and skillful writer, a writer of dozens of books? What is behind that reluctance to write a script for an essay film?
In this chapter the author examines these questions by focusing on two cases by the well-known Finnish filmmaker and writer Peter von Bagh. As his producer, he was able to observe von Bagh's work process and working methods from the ideas to the distribution of finalised films. On a more general level, the author looks at the whole process of making essay films and the role of the script in it.
Heliographies of Change: Marianna Christofides’ Days In Between (2015)
Theoretically framed by Gilles Deleuze's notion of the time-image, this article traces the palimpsestic temporalities, performative modes, and disjunctive ethos of film essayistic storytelling in Marianna Christofides' Days In Between (2015). It seeks to draw attention to the multiply inscribed, at times contrapuntal affective and aesthetic movements that mark Days In Between, as well as reflect the filmmaker's own skeptical and ambivalent stance in her encounters with Southeast Europe. It is the durational character of these repetitive encounters with a changing region that keeps the gap open, as the co-authors argue, and allows binary notions of ‘self’ and ‘other’, ‘history’ and ‘memory’ or concepts of space and time to become destabilized. The critical exploration of, and deeper felt insights into, the poetics and politics of essayistic filmmaking, in the article, take up the form of a loosely choreographed dance-for-two, resonating with the film essay's dialogic mode.
The Future of Thinking: Notes on Animation and the Essay Film
Despite its inclusion in the earliest essay films, animation was subsequently dropped in favour of the recording of personal testimony, eyewitness events and the use of archive footage. The result is, even today, a sparse number of animated essay films.
We compare examples of the more common montage based essay films with animated works, with a particular emphasis on how they materially instantiate different models of thinking - dialectical, disjunctive, computational. We compare visual logics such as montage and transformation, new relationships between media facilitated using rotoscoping and the recent use of AI. We argue that it is its broad range of artistic techniques and connections to other disciplines that now make animated media best placed to indicate the future of thinking as an audio-visual practice. In return, animation will have to confront issues of its own status as an artform, a form of media practice and as a science.
Three Sisters in a Sketchbook: Photography as Prosthesis in the Essay Film Form
Building on the research previously conducted, and looking at the narrative strategies implemented in Three Sisters in a Sketchbook (Turina 2024), the chapter deepens the reflection on how geo-cultural negotiations and spaces of historical and emotional resonance allow the essay film to investigate the archive. We look at how screenwriting strategies allow to open spaces of negotiation with silenced history, where personal trauma and personhood emerge through the circular structure of the essay film. We see how the layers of signification emerge progressively, a little more at each repetition/loop within the film, and any hypothesis formed in viewing the preceding sequences is inevitably re-negotiated and never entirely clarified. Following the path, it becomes clear how the openness of the answers not given to the audience is key to the essay film form, as the accumulation of meaning integrated into the visual solutions proposed to the audience is there to open and explore, to think. Accordingly, the idea of thought in motion related to the form becomes evident in the screenplay, as the writing of the page in its first-person format is both apt and odd in classical screenwriting.
Essay Film and Narrative Techniques
Screen-writing Non-fiction
The collection explores various methods of screen-writing for essay film, through a diverse set of reflections and analyses of canonical and unconventional approaches of essay filmmaking. It includes contributions from filmmakers and practice-led researchers, who reflect on their production process in the form of production diaries or self-critique, and analyses from scholars who investigate the production contexts of essay film, as well as interviews with filmmakers on how their practices are conceptualised and contextualised. Overall, it takes essay film as an expression of personal camera, collaborative/collective work, and experimental work where the boundaries between different art forms blurs and merges.
The Neoliberal Self in Bollywood
Cinema, Popular Culture, and Identity
This book explores the consequences of unbridled expansion of neoliberal values within India through the lens of popular film and culture. The focus of the book is the neoliberal self, which, far from being a stable marker of urban, liberal, millennial Indian identity, has a schizophrenic quality, one that is replete with contradictions and oppositions, unable to sustain the weight of its own need for self-promotion, optimism, and belief in a narrative of progress and prosperity that has marked mainstream cultural discourse in India. The unstable and schizophrenic neoliberal identity that is the concern of this book, however, belies this narrative and lays bare the sense of precarity and inherent inequality that neoliberal regimes confer upon their subjects.
The analysis is explicitly political and draws upon theories of feminist media studies, popular culture analyses, and film studies to critique mainstream Hindi cinema texts produced in the last two decades. Rele Sathe also examine a variety of other peripheral ‘texts’ in her analysis such as the film star, the urban space, web series, YouTube videos, and social media content.
Exploring homelessness in virtual reality documentary: The scripting of Rose Troche’s We Live Here (2020, USA)
US filmmaker Rose Troche has had a lengthy career as a writer and director working across film and television contexts since gaining prominence with the low-budget feature Go Fish in 1994. In more recent times, she has created several virtual reality experiences that have explored social issues such as date rape and police brutality. This chapter explores the interactive VR work We Live Here, which was produced as part of Meta’s ‘VR for Good’ programme. Created using a game engine, We Live Here is a documentary experience that takes the user into the precarious world of Rockey, a 59-year-old woman who experiences homelessness in Los Angeles, California. The VR experience begins when police ‘sweep’ a park where Rockey has pitched a tent, causing her to flee. The user is then left to enter the tent and explore her belongings, all of which activate narrative threads that reveal aspects of Rockey’s full life story.
The chapter explores the writing and creation of We Live Here, which involved collaboration with awareness-raising non-profit organization Invisible People, Los Angeles Housing and hands on research and consultation with homeless and formerly homeless people in the local community. It argues that the finished work fosters an embodied user experience of homelessness, highlighting just how easily one might find themselves in the situation of precarious living. As such, it is an impactful work that presents an innovative portrayal of its subject matter.
Young-Ah Yoo’s controversial adaptation of Kim Jiyoung, Born 1982 (2019, South Korea): A response to the South Korean #MeToo movement
The 2019 South Korean film, Kim Jiyoung, Born 1982, written by female screenwriter Young-Ah Yoo, created controversy when released by depicting the entrenched gender discrimination that Korean women face from childhood to adulthood. The storm surrounding the film was unsurprising. Yoo adapted the story from a notorious novel of the same name, which had brought feminist issues to the fore in a nation where women traditionally have faced scorn and mockery for addressing themes of gender inequality, an issue stemming from engrained patriarchal ideologies that support defined gender roles. Additionally, the film adaptation was released in the wake of Korea’s #MeToo movement, a highly volatile time that deepened tensions between feminists and traditionalists. Predictably, the film sparked strong anti-feminist sentiment, and Yoo’s adaptation could not avoid entering the debate as a contemporary response to the #MeToo movement. This chapter approaches Yoo’s adaptation of Kim Jiyoung: Born 1982 in respect of adaptation theory, focusing on her strategies to rearticulate the divisive feminist novel for a production destined for controversy. The analysis brings a screenwriter’s perspective to examine how the adaptation negotiates its commercial imperatives with the novel’s critical feminist tones while maintaining the intention to provoke public debate on gender inequality. Finally, the chapter explores the adaptation’s consequences following release and its impact on society.
The first female filmmaker in Central America: Patricia Howell, on a life of defending women’s rights and pioneering national cinema in Costa Rica
Patricia Howell broke into the Costa Rican film scene when being a filmmaker in Central America was unthinkable for anyone, and more so for a politically active and sexually diverse woman. With her groundbreaking fiction works Íntima Raíz (1984) and Lobas (2015), Patricia developed a career that spans four decades and dozens of fiction and documentary films, and has paved the way for a national cinema told from a female perspective. In this chapter, we explore the influences, main themes and methods used by Patricia in her screenplays and how activism for women’s rights became her main goal in life through motion pictures. We also review the impact that Patricia’s work has had on younger generations of Costa Rican female screenwriters and directors, and how her work has affected the country’s cultural laws to promote more women creators whose voices will be heard, thanks in part to her pioneering work.
